AFCA Leverages Enhanced Standards to Minimize Advice Complaints

2

Interestingly, the number of new complaints AFCA received in this sector fell to 3,559, a notable decrease of 26% from the preceding year. According to its annual report, AFCA attributed this decline to the positive impact of rising educational standards and heightened professionalism within the financial advisory industry.

However, challenges persist, particularly concerning the controversial case of Dixon Advisory, which continues to contribute to overall complaints. Without the Dixon Advisory-related grievances, complaints hit an all-time low of 2,709.

Lead Ombudsman for investments and advice, Shail Singh, noted during AFCA's recent member forum that outcomes were not universally favoring complainants. For instance, one claimant involved with Dixon did not suffer harm despite following conflicted advice.

Moreover, Senior Ombudsman Patrick Hartney highlighted, “When compared to what AFCA deemed appropriate advice, the complainant was actually better off with the conflicted advice result.” Hartney explained how cookie-cutter approaches to advice might have variable impacts based on individual circumstances, proving beneficial to some despite being generally suboptimal.

The AFCA annual report further elaborated that nearly half (44%) of the complaints they handled were resolved during the "rules review" phase. This stage, where issues are examined for jurisdictional appropriateness, requires detailed decision-making, explaining the average resolution timeframe of 129 days. Such intricate processes have been partly responsible for protracted case durations.

While complaint volume has decreased, the top issue remains inappropriate advice, which accounted for 706 (20%) of all complaints. Other recurring issues include confusion over the classification of Self-Managed Super Funds (SMSFs) and wholesale client status, often leading to misapplication of financial thresholds, an insight noted by Sidoti, the Senior Ombudsman.

“It’s pretty clear that actually doesn’t apply in circumstances where advice is given to a trustee to an SMSF,” confirmed Sidoti. Misapplication of these financial thresholds can categorize SMSFs inaccurately, with serious advisories issued for small balance SMSFs lacking diversification.

With market volatility influenced by national political events, the authority has observed complaint trends shifting accordingly. Beyond handling regular disputes, AFCA has now been endorsed by the government to lead an external resolution scheme under the Scams Prevention Framework, a major initiative in the governmental “war on scams”, as stated by Minister Stephen Jones.

The pilot will cover three key sectors: banks, telecommunications, and digital platforms, illustrating an expansive approach to scam management involving interconnected industries.

Published:Monday, 28th Oct 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Finance News

Clear

Investors Shift Focus to Hedged International Equity ETFs Amid Volatility 19 May 2025: Paige Estritori New insights from InvestSMART reveal a noticeable shift in investment preferences from Australian equity Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) to global equity ETFs, particularly hedged international equity ETFs. This development comes in light of investors' efforts to guard against currency fluctuations. - read more

RBA Rate Cut Possible Despite Eased US-China Tariffs 19 May 2025: Paige Estritori Economists are largely forecasting that the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) will reduce interest rates during its upcoming meeting, although recent international developments add some uncertainty to this prediction. Notably, US President Donald Trump's decision to lower tariffs on China prompted a reciprocal tariff reduction by Beijing, leading to a rise in risk asset values, including shares. - read more

Australia Records Historic Fall in Disposable Income 16 May 2025: Paige Estritori Recent data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) revealed a historical drop in real per capita household disposable income for Australians, marking an unprecedented fall of around 8% since mid-2022. This decline represents a significant issue, with Australia experiencing the largest decrease in the developed world, according to the OECD. - read more

Record High Australian House Prices Exceed $11 Trillion 16 May 2025: Paige Estritori Australia’s housing market has reached a significant milestone, with the total value of housing stock hitting $11.3 trillion as of April 2025. According to Cotality, formerly CoreLogic, the average home is now valued at $1 million, underscoring the considerable growth in property values. - read more

ASX Hits 11-Week High Amidst US-China Tariff Pause 14 May 2025: Paige Estritori The Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) reached its highest level in 11 weeks, buoyed by the announcement of a temporary pause in tariff increases between the United States and China. The ASX 200 index climbed 35.50 points, or 0.43%, to 8,269, with standout performances from the energy and information technology sectors. Similarly, the All Ordinaries index saw a rise of 43.70 points, or 0.52%, closing at 8,510.70. The Australian dollar also appreciated, gaining 0.71% to 64.16 US cents. - read more